Meanwhile, US gross domestic product (GDP) has returned to, and even exceeded, its pre-crisis level. Moreover, fiscal policy is also very expansionary and inflation risks are on the rise. The shortage of intermediate goods and raw materials has taken on huge dimensions, with US producer prices recently increasing by an annualised 8.3%. The surge in energy costs is particularly disturbing. Granted, the price of natural gas in the States has risen far less sharply than in Europe thanks to America’s self-sufficiency; nonetheless, it has tripled year-on-year.
Although consumer price inflation should retreat significantly from the current 5%+ level, the question remains as to where it will actually come to rest in 2022. Thus it should come as no surprise that not just the Fed, but also the ECB and other major central banks are starting to talk about heightened inflation risks.
The monetary authorities are sensing the need for action on their part, despite the risks to the global economy posed by today’s material shortages. They have at their disposal well-stocked toolboxes that make it possible to pull off the delicate balancing act between inflation and economic disruption. For example, a tapering off of the Fed’s monthly securities purchases will not cause the US economy to stumble, but it does send a clear signal that the central bank will not stand idly by as inflation risks increase.
The Fed is dealing with the situation
The September FOMC meeting minutes made it patently clear: the US economy has come closer to hitting the Fed’s employment and inflation targets, which in turn justifies a reduction of its asset purchases. Chairman Jerome Powell hinted that tapering will on the agenda at the FOMC meeting scheduled for 2-3 November, going so far as to say that bond purchases could be completely discontinued already by the middle of next year. This pace would be much faster than the previous taper eight years ago, when the Fed took all of ten months (December 2013 until October 2014) to complete the task.
Since this past June, the Fed has been buying securities at a net monthly rate of USD 120 billion. Were it to spread the reduction evenly over eight months (assumption: start in November, end in June), the monthly volume would have to be reduced by around USD 15 billion. Also conceivable is a taper that would begin gently and then gradually increase in size. However, that strategy strikes us as being unlikely since the Fed would then need to step on the brakes too hard in 2022. In the previous taper, the Fed also took an even-handed approach in trimming its monthly purchases, namely by USD 10 billion a shot.
How will things go after the taper?
Following the taper, the Fed will probably leave its balance sheet total unchanged at least for a while and merely reinvest the proceeds from maturing issues as its focus returns to more conventional measures. The FOMC’s projections published in September imply that the members envisage an initial rate hike already in 2022. By logical extension, this suggests that the first rate move could actually take place shortly after the taper is concluded. This, too, would indicate that the Fed intends to recalibrate at a much faster pace than it did back in October 2014, when the initial post-taper hike followed only in December of 2015.
According to the aforementioned projections, the Fed funds rate could rise to one per cent by the end of 2023, which would involve three 25bp rate bumps. So it would appear that the Fed is in somewhat of a hurry. The rapid economic recovery and heightened inflation risks are indeed being taken into account in the central bank’s monetary policy deliberations.
How the financial markets react(ed)
Even before the Fed made its first tapering move in 2013, bond yields skyrocketed in an episode that has gone down in financial market annals as the “taper tantrum”. However, seemingly blind to the whole affair, the equity markets continued to march higher. And nothing changed in that respect, even in the face of the rate hikes that were ultimately introduced in late 2015. The reason: Tapering simply means that the monthly bond purchases are being reduced, yet the Fed's balance sheet grows further as the economy continues to receive monetary support. It is precisely this fact that keeps the financial markets happy. Equally spoken, the current rise in yields is likely to persist this time around. The long end of the yield curve also reflects market expectations at the short end. In other words, since tapering signals that the Fed intends to raise interest rates at some point in the future, we believe that yields on longer-dated Treasuries will rise gradually, with 10-year T-bonds initially taking aim at the 2% mark.
A glance back at the previous monetary tightening cycle reveals that the financial markets only then started to unravel once the Fed’s balance sheet was shrinking in tandem with rising interest rates. The balance sheet slimdown commenced in October 2017 when the central bank stopped reinvesting the proceeds from redeemed issues. Initially, the diet started with a USD 10 billion monthly reduction and then gradually increased by increments of USD 10 billion to a point where the balance sheet total was shrinking by USD 50 billion each month until the process was completed in September 2019. The associated reduction in the money supply was temporarily reflected by higher risk premiums in the money markets, which in turn caused a spike in equity market volatility. In general it can be said that the interest rate sensitivity of stocks has increased in recent years, seeing as how the overall valuation level is relatively high and the share of growth stocks has also risen. In short, the real stress test will come only once the money supply starts to drop.
S&P 500 and monetary policy, 2013 > 2019